Episode Transcript
[00:00:00] Speaker A: Welcome to Missouri Corn Talk, your go to weekly agriculture podcast delivering fast, reliable updates on market development efforts, ethanol demand, and the issues shaping today's corn industry. I'm your host, David Geiger. Corn growers rely on USDA reports to help make marketing decisions. But when those numbers are wrong, the consequences can reach well beyond a government report. A recent error in USDA September corn estimates has raised serious questions about the accuracy of the data and the impact on farmers already facing tight margins. Joining us is Matt Frostic, a Michigan farmer and president of the National Corn Growers Association. Matt, thanks for joining us. Let's start with the impact on farmers. What has this error meant for corn growers who are trying to market their crop in an already challenging price environment?
[00:00:44] Speaker B: Yeah, I mean, this past year has been a huge challenge to not only the corn growers of America, but the farmers, the ag in general.
Anybody that's involved in commodities with higher prices, we've had to address and the challenges with that and you know, getting this crop in the ground and then some of the challenges with quality throughout the Midwest has been a struggle here too. But this latest incidents, you know, when it comes to, to WASB reports and things like that, while they may not always get them right and, and they will average out through the year, we, we do give credit to that. The timing of this current one is what this, what is frustrating to, to growers. It comes at a time when we're at harvest that crops coming in. There's not necessarily a huge certainty of what we have yet.
And with all that, the, the bills that are associated with this crop are coming due too. So with the, with the report that gives so much uncertainty and lacks credibility, I guess you could say it at, at some point, the market really doesn't like to have those type of surprises in it. So it takes a lot of time to build that trust back in. Well, in the meantime, there's farmers out there that have to make payments in the next 60 to 90 days.
And when we see nearly a dollar pulled out of the market and a bushel of corn that's pretty substantial across the American Midwest on the balance sheets, that's what's frustrating. Will it balance out? I'm sure it will, but how much time it takes is a question.
And many, many of these growers will not be able to take advantage of it just because of the timing of the incidents.
[00:02:29] Speaker A: This market impact is very real for farmers. We saw a drastic drop off after the release of some recent reports.
How do you approach that, how do you approach this correction that we have, because corrections are not abnormal when it comes to the usda. They will from time to time make some changes, make some updates. What makes this correction so different than previous ones and raises these questions.
[00:02:52] Speaker B: It looks, and we don't know yet, we need to meet with them and just help understand better what actually happened. But it looks like fundamental mistakes were made that, you know, quite frankly, if I did on my farm or, or something like that, we would, you know, we would be in a little bit of trouble for it. So it's, it's probably the nature of the mistakes that have happened and then just that, oh, well, it'll average out and it'll be fine. That is really hard to accept from the industry.
Again, because of that timing.
[00:03:25] Speaker A: Farmers need to have confidence in USDA numbers. It's an open, freely available source that helps create certainty in a field that has very little. So uncertainty in a lot of different areas of its business.
What do you suggest, what are the corn growers going to talk about and suggest to the USDA when those meetings do happen?
[00:03:48] Speaker B: I think we'll, we'll certainly start off by talking about how the relevance of these reports, how impactful they are to, to the grower and in the markets. I mean, that's first and foremost. We know that there's been work being done to improve NAS statistics and being more efficient and integrating technology to make them better. And that's going to take time and that's been happening even before this situation.
So that's important and we're willing, we need to work with them to get that done. When we look at survey reports, I think back 20, 25 years ago, they would get, you know, 70, 80% returns, returns on those surveys. So the information was quite a bit more accurate than, than today, where we're only seeing like 20% returns on those surveys. So we've got to find better ways to get information and data from, from the industry. There's been a lot of resentment, a lack of trust and a lack of, from growers on the, on those data sets. They seem to come at times when they can move the market in the wrong direction and not in the favor of the growers.
And those are some of the sentiments we're hearing from growers, you know, even before this. So this one just is quite a bit larger when you, when you look at it, and certainly at a time when there's a dire need for some good news or some solid footing in this industry that needs to happen. We, we are looking at some of some of the lower prices we've seen in corn today and some of the highest prices again in fertilizer for this 27 crop. That's, that's important to note because the last three, four years we've lost money growing this crop 20, the tune of 140 to $60 an acre on the national average.
[00:05:34] Speaker A: That farmer confidence is a really difficult challenge. There are significantly fewer farmers than there used to be when that 70% rate was at that level. How do you approach that topic as you, as you go to the usda? Are there some suggestions you're going to bring through this process?
[00:05:53] Speaker B: Yeah, I think transparency is so important.
Transparency from inputs to the cost of the products that we're buying to transparency of selling is so important on all ends. If we have to be that transparent, then obviously then the rest of the market should be to, to, to keep it fair and even.
[00:06:14] Speaker A: So you're going to approach the USDA and an issue that may come up is simply all of the other farm related goings on. At the moment we have NASS potentially still waiting on this decision to move to Kansas City. So you might have employee movements or layoffs or new hirings. You have the farm bill still not done after many, many years of waiting for a farm bill to get done.
How do you navigate this situation when there are so many different influencers and you really just want to make sure that you're hitting on this narrow topic or maybe it does touch those other things. So it's a good point to bring up at the same time.
[00:07:00] Speaker B: Yeah, I think it's shows why we need a farm bill to stabilize what we do in the usda. It demonstrates, you know, we've been renewing a farm bill from 2018 for the last three, four years. Well, we can do that for a year or two and survive. As we continue down that road and keep renewing numbers that are Quite frankly almost 10 years old, it becomes, it starts to scar the market and create holes in it like this.
So that's why it's important that we get a farm bill pass this year with like an E15 attachment to it to build some, some footing in this industry, to build those domestic markets, to create solidarity in the financial institutions that our ag industry is strong and we will be here in 27.
Right now that's up for question at this point.
[00:07:56] Speaker A: Ultimately, this all circles around to farmer participation. It's a big part of how the Corn Growers association at the state and national level function. And it also is how these USDA surveys also Work.
What is your suggestion to farmers listening on, participating in the process to make their voices heard and to also let the USDA know what's going on?
[00:08:20] Speaker B: That's a tough question. I mean, it's hard to build confidence in this data collection when there's been so many years of just the sentiments of it have been negative.
I think we've got to come to the table and come up with some creative ideas to build integrity back into the system and then spread that amongst the industry. I think if we can, you know, inject technology into this, there's, there's lots of other data sets we can possibly use to back check or verify what we're doing versus just a survey report. So there's other avenues that we can use that are already there that I think may be even better than a survey that could help bring more realistic numbers to this, to our system.
[00:09:07] Speaker A: Matt, is there anything you'd like to add that I didn't touch on or that you'd like to include in this conversation?
[00:09:12] Speaker B: As an organization, we're here to get answers and to find answers, and so that's what's important. We want to work with the usda. We want to be able to sit down with them and figure out how we can work together.
So this is that first step of getting there. We do have meetings scheduled to do so, and so that's important to, to get that first step down. So, yeah, it's part of building a better industry and having confidence in everything we do. And it needs to start now and, and work on getting a better, better system in place. When we can build that confidence back in the system, obviously our industry will come along along the way, and I think we'll thrive from it.
[00:09:53] Speaker A: Matt, thank you so much for joining us and sharing the perspective of corn growers across the country.
[00:09:57] Speaker B: Yeah, thank you.
[00:09:59] Speaker A: Farmers make important decisions on USDA reports, and they need to trust the numbers. Correcting an error is one step, but restoring confidence will take accountability, better quality control, and a reporting process that encourages farmers to participate. This week's corn talk is made possible by the Missouri Corn Merchandising Council and the Missouri Corn Growers Association. To learn more about Missouri Corn's efforts to build demand for corn at home and around the world, visit mocorn.org or follow on our social channels. I'm David Geiger. Thanks for listening.